KEITH WILSON – I had the pleasure of hearing conservative columnist and author David Brooks speak the other night. I watch him weekly on PBS News Hour and have read two of his books, “The Social Animal” and “The Road to Character.” He was invited to my city by a church known for being inclusive. While his speech and following Q/A was filled with poignant quotes and observations, his caution that “we are over-politicized and under-moralized” resonated with me.
His speech was far more focused on America’s changes over time than it was political. He noted we were much more community oriented before 1968, but still had many faults around racIsm, bigotry and gender inequality. He noted the gains we have made post-1968, but we also tore down institutional cache and became more individually minded, even more narcissistic in nature, as he explained with a few key statistics. He thoughtfully spoke of how we have come to the current tribalism in America. He noted tribalism is based more on fear and hatred of others than it is love for your tribe.
This was occurring long before Trump and he said he frankly did not think Trump would win. He said people are disenfranchised and want to be heard. To Trump’s credit he reached out to these folks, yet he sold a message of fear and isolationism. An example of one of Brooks’ quotes from this night is “Trump is the wrong answer to the right question.”
From his travels, reading and teaching, he noted people are thirsty for moral direction. We desire a moral compass. We want to do the right thing, but we have become so lonely and alienated (he again accentuated his assertion with relevant statistics) we have limited our avenues to a community mindset. We are not talking to one another and have looked less to institutions and more to movements.
Early on he defined we are consumed by both a “desiring heart” and “yearning soul.” We want to love someone and belong. We want to find contentment for our soul and nurture it. This is why we long for a sense of community or family. He noted an answer to a previous time in the 1890s when we became so disenfranchised, we saw community movements that led to better working conditions, the suffragette movement, the temperance movement, environmental protection, etc.
That is likely the same kind of answer we need to diminish this tribalism. We need to seek community oriented solutions. He said our places of faith can be more helpful, but need to focus on our being better people and picking each other up. He noted an example of a man in Shreveport who helped identify a community house in each area of the city. The house would be a place where BBQs, community events, fellowship, parties et al could happen.
When someone asked what is a key takeaway, he laughed and said that is your job as I just throw out ideas. Then, he eloquently noted a story about a psychologist who was captured by the Nazis and placed in a detention camp. The question no longer was what should I do with my life? The question was now what does life have in store for me? He said that may be the better question we should ask ourselves today.
As he left the stage, I witnessed a humble man who seemed to be saying through his body language, why are you clapping for me? He deserved the adoration. Even the minister of the church noted Brooks’ message had a strong sense of a Judeo-Christian ethic as it was seasoned with pertinent biblical references. We need more voices like him. We need more discussions like these.
Charlotte, Independent Voter, Advocate for the disenfranchised, debt education and the environment